Listener Challenge: Name That Sound!
In what movie did this sound appear?
And how did Ben Burtt make it? TELL US!
June 27, 2008
Name that sound: Indiana Jones - whiplash sound
I came to say the same thing as Robert in comment #1: Indiana Jones's whip. You can tell by the music.
That's Indy's bullwhip. Made by release a wire or line under tension?
It is definitely the bullwhip sound from raiders of the lost ark. I think the sound could possibly have been created from an electrical arc?
That is Indiana Jones' bullwhip and it was made with a clothesline (or similar) being whipped back in forth in air and a rubber band being plucked against a surface (maybe on a notebook) and some type of random thud like a rubber mallet on heavy wood joist. Ballpark.
Well, I was going to say the whip from Indiana Jones...
the bull whip. I imagine the sound was made by speeding up something metal, resembling the shape of a whip, like a metal wire.
the whip from Dr Jones
It is Indiana Jones' bullwhip. It is from Raiders of the Lost Arc. The noise is made by a sliding down a wire under tension (like a zipline)and getting faster and faster. At the end, the thing on the wire smashes into whatever is at the end of the wire.
It's Indy's whip, that was easy. How did he make it? I'm not sure, it sure sounds like a microphone cord that's been whipped through water.
Another here for the Indy whip.
Now the hard part: How?
Is it obvious or obtuse? Oh the pressure!
I feel there are two components; First is the woosh sound so air may be involved, like a fast narrow intake of air. Second is the crack part - metal or paper --- I'm stumped!
Well, it's definitely the famous Indiana Jones "bull whip" that's called into use whenever the situation seems hopeless.
I would guess that the sound is a composite of two sounds: the first a microphone being spun at the end of a long cord and the final "crack" seems like a slap of some kind, for example slapping your hand against your thigh. I suppose one could replay the first very quickly and add the second while recording the simulation.
Indiana Jones Whip.
Music is a giveaway.
Good story, by the way.
I have to wonder if this is one of those rare occasions of reality in sound effects. Could the bull whip sound be a recording of a bull whip? I imagine the whoosh part of it would have to be amplified to be heard in relation to the crack at the end, and perhaps modified for a Doppler effect appropriate to the scene?
Indiana Jones' whip. It was made by recording a hand-clap. The tape starts out at less-than 1/2 speed (the approach of the whip) and then speeds back up to regular speed at the cresendo. (the "crack" of the whip / hand clap)
Well, I was going to identify the sound as that caused by Dr. Jones, Jr.'s whip, but after seeing so many other listeners guess the same, I must now take exception. It is quite possible that the sound is in fact a field recording of the mysterious and reclusive Indian Whip Elephant. The "music" one seems to hear is in fact the distinctive trumpeting of the elephant, and the whipping sound is actually produced by the unusually long tail of the females of the species. This whipping behaviour is believed to be defensive posturing, so beware the cornered female Indian Whip Elephant. Rumor has it Mssr.s Speilburg and Lucas obtained a recording of the elephant at a bazar in Goa, but who knows?
Like everyone is saying it is obviously the whip of Indiana Jones. I think it is made by whipping a branch and then cracking it.
The sound is definitely from Indiana Jones - the whiplash sound.; created by thin metal plates or something…
Ah yes. This is from the scene in Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark. Specifically, this is the Moracco scene when Indiana is backing off two extras in a wide ally. The sound I believe, is a real whip, in a recording studio with hard wood floor or concrete floor that had a thick paint on it.
Thanks!!
Joshua
Indiana Jones and the Temple of DOOM!!!!!! The part where the guy in all red has a rock in his hand and Indiana whips his hand!!!
Still beleive it was made with a real whip in a studio with a hard floor.
The sound is Indian Jones whip cracking. If it is the original whip crack from Raiders of the Lost Ark, then Ben Burt made this sound by recording an actual whip cracking. But I've also heard that the other sound used for the wooshing sound of the whip is Harrier Jet.
Indiana Jones, The sound of his whip. By hitting a stock of celery against a Propeller.
Harrison Ford showing the sound guys how to use a bull whip?
It's Indiana Jones' bull-whip, and Burtt made it by combining the sound of a bullwhip with the (sped-up) sound of a Harriet jet flying by (the 'whoosh' element of the sound).
It is definitely Indiana Jones' whip. The sound may be a combination of a flex of a guitar string reverberating and or thin metal bent and let go (flashing material?) and a real whip crack. Great interview, Bert!
It's Indiana Jones's whip. I think it sounds like one of those high speed sleds.
I think it is obvious that it was Indiana Jones' whip. I think it was made by combining the sound of a piece of sheet metal and a rat trap.
I also definitely thought it was the Indiana Jones whip. To me, it sounds like a thick cord being ripped apart and snapping, perhaps a telephone wire or something like that.
whip from Indiana Jones - he used an actual whip
Just hearing it, I'd have guessed it was made with a tape measure.
That is the infamous "whhishcrack" of Indianna Jones' bull whip and I believe it was created by using a real whip.
The sound is Indiana Jones' Bull whip. I'd guess that the whipping part of the sound is made from paper being ripped starting fast, ending slow, and then played backward. Over top of that you'd put paper being ripped fast (playing forward), and the last crack probably is a whip against a loose thin plastic sheet of some kind.
Please keep your comments relevant to this entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments on Studio 360 are moderated. Studio 360 reserves the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the studio360.org Comment Guidelines before posting.
<< Back to Episode
Studio 360 is a co-production of
Public
Radio International and
WNYC New York Public Radio, and is funded in part by
Ken and Lucy Lehman, the
National Endowment for the Arts, the Lily Auchincloss Foundation, and
DK Eyewitness Travel. Studio 360's American Icons series is supported in part by the
National Endowment for the Humanities. Our series on creativity and science is supported in part by the
Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. Our series on Underground Heroes is supported in part by the New York State Music Fund, established by the New York State Attorney General at Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors. ![]()