Gary Marcus: Defining Creativity

Interview

Friday, April 26, 2013

Kurt Andersen talks with Gary Marcus about what science knows, and doesn’t know, about creativity. Marcus is the director of New York University’s Center for Language and Music, and the author of Guitar Zero, a book about how the brain learns.

Marcus is skeptical of tests that measure creativity, like the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking. “They correlate somewhat with actual achievement. It’s like measuring someone’s height and saying, ‘Are they going to be a good basketball player?’ On average, taller people are better basketball players. But it’s an average, and it’s a pretty indirect measure.”

The key problem for all scientific approaches to creativity, Marcus thinks, is that creativity isn’t one thing; there is no box in the brain. Instead, he sees an interplay of personality traits and particular aptitudes that develop over time. “I think I’m creative as a scientist and as a writer. I’m not creative as an artist or as a musician,” he says, although Marcus writes music. Being good at songwriting, or any other field, involves too many separate skills and abilities for science to locate what is happening. But components of the skill might be definable. “Being good at rhymes,” he suggests. “That might be a fine enough ability that science could [one day] nail it down, and say ‘this is how the brain gets good at rhyme.’”

Marcus emphasizes that mastering conventions of a field (and when to break them) is a key component of art making. But “part of creativity,” he says, “is just the guts to break the rules.” He wants creative scientists working in his own lab, of course. “The thing I care about the most is: are they troubleshooters, problem solvers? In the real world of science, nothing ever goes as planned, and you want people who sit there and try to fix it.” This is true in aspects of art making as well, he points out. “You try out a chord structure and it doesn’t work. Either you sit there and look at it, or you say ‘How can I make this better?’”

(Originally aired: November 23, 2012)

    Music Playlist
  • The Girl From Back Then (Riton's Über Jazz Mix)
    Artist: Kings of Convenience
    Album: Versus
    Label: CAROLINE ASTRALWERKS - CAT
    Purchase: Amazon

Guests:

Gary Marcus

Produced by:

David Krasnow

Comments [1]

oh boy!

As someone who just endured full brain nuking, then learned just how much "we" know about the brain (very little per every neuroscientist I ever heard, incl. a Nobel Laureate recently on Leonard Lopate - VERY LITTLE! It will take 100 years per this Nobel laureate before we really start to know much about the brain.

Why do we need to pin down and control creativity?

This fellow who is talking right now really resonates for me - is he called Jerry Lanier?

Apr. 28 2013 11:49 AM

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.